Vs. Nursing Homes
Assisted Living Compared to Nursing Homes
How is an Assisted Living Facility different from a Nursing Home?
Families and seniors get confused on which place is better to live: Assisted living or Nursing home. Don't be mistaken--they're very different!
Both have differences... and similarities. Sometimes, a retirement community offers both; assisted living and a nursing home facility. That's called a continuum of care retirement community (CCRC).
Continuum of care is an integrated system of care that monitors and tracks a resident over time through an all-inclusive range of health services. The model encourages the delivery of optimum health care to the residents.
Facilities that offer a continuum of care have both nursing home services and assisted living residences. In addition, a nursing home is the term that has been most commonly used for senior residences that offer healthcare while assisted living is a more recent type of senior care offering that caters to those who seek a bit less care and more independence.
Assisted Living Facilities
Adults view assisted living as an independent option because they have the safeguard that personal care and support services is there, if needed. These support services include; basic ADLs (activities of daily living) like bathing, grooming, dressing, and toileting. Because individual states regulate assisted living facilities, not federal, some states allow facilities to offer medication assistance and/or reminders.
ALFs range from standalone apartments or cottages, to studio, a one bedroom, or a large shared one bedroom. The environment is appealing because it feels like home. Kitchenettes are available and feature a small refrigerator and microwave.
Assisted living does not offer complex medical services.
The main difference between assisted living facilities and nursing homes is the level of care a resident receives and the freedom given to the resident.
In nursing homes, residents are under constant medical supervision, in need of assistance with daily living and are not capable of living independently anymore, at all.
The residents in a nursing home are more like patients and unable to leave the facility on their own, mainly because they are physically or mentally powerless. While some residents in assisted living might need assistance with medicine management, bathing and other tasks, they are capable of handling most of the daily living activities on their own.
Assisted living residents might still drive, cook their own meals, come and go freely, have security of medical supervision, and social interaction with other residents. Nursing home residents do not.
Nursing homes provide living options for seniors in needs of varying levels of medical supervision for years while assisted living residences have become more popular in the last few decades.
Nursing Homes Deliver Complex Medical Services
Skilled Care - Intensive skilled care administered to patients requiring specialized care. Residents admitted to skilled nursing homes require constant monitoring, with complex medical procedures and services given by registered nurses. Complex medical services or intensive care treatment involves ventilator services, severe wound management, and tracheotomy care.
Skilled Nursing and Rehab Care - This care is under supervision of a licensed medical physician and administered on a daily basis by either a registered nurse or licensed practical nurse. It's often a part of a rehabilitation process administered as a long-term aid for a chronic illness or surgery. Skilled nursing procedures are wound care, intravenous injections, and feeding.
Intermediate Care - Most residents at this level are experiencing a long-term physical or emotional illness and are stable but need a registered nurse to monitor them. Intermediate care examples are physical therapy, administration of medication, and medical supervision.
Custodial care - does not apply to a medical condition and administered by non-medical personnel. Custodial care gives help in feeding, bathing and dressing.
Assisted Living Delivers Less Complex Medical Services
- Access to health care and medical services customized to specific needs.
- Assistance with eating, bathing, dressing, toileting, and walking as needed
- 24-hour emergency call systems for each resident
- Three meals a day served in dining area, housekeeping, and laundry services.
- Shuttle buses and transportation
- Exercise and wellness programs
- Other services you can expect to receive at an assisted living facility:
- Available staff available to meet needs
- 24-hour assistance with activities of daily living: Bathing, dressing, grooming, toileting
- Three meals a day and snacks between meals
- Housekeeping services
- Transportation as needed
- Pharmacy, barber and beautician, and/or physical therapy services offered on-site
Facility Differences between Assisted Living and Nursing Homes
When thinking about nursing homes, a person associates it with limited privacy like 2 beds to a room, nurses or aides roaming the halls and checking on residences while providing medical assistance. There are cafeterias and social areas where the residents eat and interact.
Although many assisted living facilities resemble nursing homes, many licensed assisted living residences are drastically different. They range from a converted house that looks more like a bed and breakfast to a huge campus with numerous apartments. Since each state sets regulations on assisted living licensing, there is a wide diversity of licensed assisted living residences.
The table below compares the services of a Nursing Home and an Assisted Living Facility:
Comparison of services offered in Assisted Living Facilities | Nursing Homes
Assisted Living | Nursing Homes
Minor Medical Supervision Yes | Yes
Extensive Medical Care No | Yes
Personal Care Assistance (bathing, dressing, etc.) Yes | Yes
24-hour supervision Yes | Yes
Security and Emergency Call Systems Yes | Yes
Housekeeping Services Yes | Yes
Social Activities Yes | Yes
Meals Yes | Yes
Resident's Freedom More | Independence More Restrictive
Transportation Yes | Yes
Most Resident's Health Average | Health Issues More Severe Health Problems
Private Pay In Many Cases | Medicaid Accepted
Please note the comparisons above are to illustrate the general differences between typical assisted living facilities and nursing homes. In many cases, assisted living facilities are on campuses or in the same building complex as nursing homes, so the types of services available vary. Since no nationwide standard exists that defines assisted living facilities, the range of services offered vary greatly too.
After seven years of helping her aging parents, Carol Marak has become a dedicated senior care writer. Since 2007, she has been doing the research to find answers to common concerns: housing, aging and health, staying safe and independent, and planning long-term.
Questions from Our Readers
- What can be done when the assisted living home caregivers threaten a conservator?
- What is your availability at this location?
- Violations on Assisted Living Homes
- Who can I report an issue to for a California Assisted Living Home
- Can a nursing home restrict a patient from using a powered wheelchair?
- How do I find * ratings on nursing homes and how often does the state inspect them?
- Need a nursing home/assisted living paid by Medicare for my Mom she is 96
- Can you provide a list of AFC Homes in Sanilac County that accept state payments
- 30 year old quadrapelic on social security as income looking for assisted living care
- Care Homes for younger people with Memory Loss
- What is Assisted Living?
- Who Lives in Assisted Living?
- Services Provided
- Staff and Administration
- Quiz: What type of care is right for me?
- Talking to a Parent
- Assisted Living Costs
- Ways to Pay for Assisted Living
- Putting Together a Financial Plan
- If You Can't Afford Assisted Living
- Planning Your Social Security to Better Pay for Retirement
- Prescription Drug Assistance
- Choosing an Assisted Living Facility
- Moving Out of the Family Home
- Moving Into an Assisted Living Community
- Resident Activities
- Resident Health
- Medication Management and Adherence Education
- How Tech Advanced are Facilities?
- General Facts and Statistics
- History of Assisted Living
- Trends in the Industry
- Industry Expert Interviews